“We must aim to stay on a creative learning curve, consciously not using words we’ve used too many times before or falling back into the same old pattern each time we compose a song. The poet is always aiming to say old things in a new way — or as Brian Doerksen puts it, universal themes in a unique way.” — Paul Baloche in God Songs: How To Write And Select Songs For Worship (w/ Jimmy & Carol Owens).
We sing to God (Psalm 100:1-2), and God sings to us (Zephaniah 3:17). Music has always been important to God’s people because music is important to God.
But many people today speak disparagingly of “Christian music” – even Christians. Part of the debate centers on music for the church versus music from the church, the latter of which might be about subjects such as romance, war, growing up, growing old, working, playing or anything else.
At My Song In The Night, we love good music – whether it’s labeled “sacred” or “secular.” But we’re focusing here on music for the church – hymns, worship songs, praise choruses and psalms. And even within this focus, a lot of Christians feel the music they sing in church pales in comparison to the music they hear on the radio. They speak disparagingly of:
- 7/11 Songs – seven words, repeated eleven times
- “Jesus Is My Boyfriend” songs – songs that might be about Jesus, or that might be about the hunk or hottie at your local pool.
- Me-Centered Worship – songs that tell God how great our love for Him is, how bodacious our praise is … and say almost nothing about Him.
- Vague theology — worship songs that could be sung word-for-word with equal fervor by worshipers of any monotheistic religion.
Good contemporary “worship music” songwriters exist, and are adding songs to the church canon that should last (Matt Redman, for instance, and Sovereign Grace Music). But we’ve all heard songs like the kind referenced above.
Why have some church songs lasted for hundreds of years, while others sound embarrassing within a decade of their creation? Are bad music and cheesy lyrics keeping people from examining the Christian faith?
These are the kind of things we’ll explore at My Song In The Night. For a more in-depth look at what makes modern hymns different from many other worship lyrics, visit our Modern Hymns page. This page will also be helpful if you arrange or write music for old hymns, or if you write other kinds of songs and want to add some different techniques to your songwriting. And follow our blog, specifically blog categories like:
What criteria or standard will we use? Music critic Marcus Grey provided a helpful formula in his analysis of the best of Bob Dylan’s gospel songs. Whether you agree with his assessment or the tone of his remarks, the formula:
fresh + well grounded in traditional strengths + passionate + authentic saturation in biblical teaching = gravitas
is strong. Grey’s remarks:
“… the best of them (Dylan’s gospel songs) surely comprise a body of work that brings to contemporary religious song something fresh yet well-grounded in traditional strengths, something passionate and full of an authentic saturation in biblical teaching. Anyone can hear that it wipes the floor with all that awful Pat Boonery, that horrid, pallid, acoustic-guitar-and-tambourine sing-song modernism and those gruesome Age of Aquarius lasers-and-love productions offered … over the last thirty years. Dylan’s religious work has gravitas.”
Songwriters, lets take our responsibility seriously. Let’s learn and grow together, for the glory of God. Don’t reach for the easy cliché. Let’s stretch. Let’s embrace the best Christian hymnody of the past even as we rush into a future where music for the church is a credit to the church, and the God who inspires our songs.